Prime Minister Abe’s address at the joint meeting of the U.S. Congress was enthusiastically received with over ten standing ovations from the participating Congressmen and observers. After the address, the Speaker of the House, Representative John Boehner, issued a statement, “We can hope future generations will look back on this day as a proud and pivotal moment in the history of our alliance.”
Apart from those who are sure to make negative criticisms, Prime Minister Abe’s address was generally positively received by the U.S. Congress and the community of those involved in Asian policy in the United States.
Dana Rohrabacher, a member of the House of Representatives and a former speechwriter for President Ronald Reagan, told reporters that the Prime Minister addressed the issues of historical perception with dignity and gave the address an “A-plus.” The Wall Street Journal also appraised that Prime Minister Abe Shinzo delivered a vintage performance at the joint meeting.
There were many ingenious references in the Prime Minister’s address that captured the hearts of the U.S. audience. At the beginning of the address, the Prime Minister named distinguished figures in the Congress who been ambassadors to Japan and referenced late Senator Daniel Inouye. This led the audience to realize that the U.S. Congress had steadily supported the U.S.–Japan alliance. The Prime Minister’s private memories, mainly from his stay in the United States when he was a student, also provided additional color to the address.
In particular, the Prime Minister touched the hearts of the audience when he mentioned the deep repentance that he felt during his visit to the World War II Memorial and said, “I offer with profound respect my eternal condolences to the souls of all American people that were lost during World War II.” Caught by emotion, some Congressmen present reportedly had tears in their eyes.
The handshake between Lt. Gen. Snowden Lawrence and the former Minister of Internal Affairs and Communications Shindo Yoshitaka, a grandson of General Kuribayashi Tadamichi, who was the commander in chief of the Japanese garrison during the Battle of Iwo Jima, was a well-arranged scene that embodied the significance of overcoming the position of the winner and the loser. This display, a model of the power of reconciliation, which occurred during the Japan–U.S. summit joint statement, was a powerful moment that showed the strong reconciliation between Japan and the United States.
By stating feelings of deep remorse, and the fact that Japan’s actions brought suffering to the people of Asian counties, and by upholding the views expressed by previous prime ministers, Prime Minister Abe responded to the deepest concerns of the audience to a certain extent. As these statements were made after his deep condolences for the American people who died in the war, the audience must have taken the statements as sincere feelings of remorse.
Loud self-assertion is often considered to be a way to strengthen public diplomacy, but if such an assertion is not accepted by the counterparties, it becomes meaningless. In this respect, the Prime Minister’s address has been evaluated as one that stated what needed to be stated in accordance with the discourse in the United States.
The success of the address can actually be judged by whether or not its purposes in terms of public diplomacy was achieved more than how it was received by the audience.
In my opinion, the first purpose was to prevent the widespread acceptance in the United States of the allegations made by China and South Korea that Japan is the one destabilizing the region, mainly due to historical perception. The second purpose was to ensure support in the United States for the alliance with Japan by strongly supporting the international order and regional order led by the United States and showing Japan’s readiness to share responsibility.
The Prime Minister’s address accomplished these purposes appropriately. The strong reconciliation between Japan and the United States has been obtained and the way Prime Minister Abe addressed the historical issues has clearly been accepted by the majority of the people in the United States. As long as Japan itself does not stray from the line it has set out, neither China nor South Korea can expect to have a strong impact on the United States, even if they make an effort to make an issue of historical perception in the United States. Moreover, the Prime Minister concluded his address by stating Japan’s proactive stance in the fields of the economy and security and referring to the Japan–U.S. alliance as an alliance of hope. This is believed to have left an impression with the positive characteristics of the alliance.
The Prime Minister’s address must be evaluated appropriately from the aspect that it made it possible to revive Japan’s initiative in international public relations in the year commemorating the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II, a seemingly unfavorable environment for Japan. On the other hand, if the Abe administration takes disappointing actions in relation to certain issues, such as in a new statement from the Prime Minister in August, TPP or the U.S. bases in Japan, opinions in the United States may change easily. The address made by President Park Geun-hye at a joint meeting of the U.S. Congress was received enthusiastically in 2013, but the relationship between the United States and South Korea has not necessarily been sound since.
In essence, like diplomacy, public diplomacy have no end either. It is expected that by taking advantage of the horizon that the Prime Minister’s address has explored, and by striving to exert synergies through appropriate actions both in Japan and overseas, new opportunities for public diplomacy will be created continually.
Translated from “Abe Shusho Enzetsu — Shikisha no Me (1): Abe Shusho no Bei Gikai Enzetsu wa Kokusaikoho ni okeru Inishiachibu wo Kaifuku saseta (Experts’ Views on Prime Minister Abe Shinzo’s Address (1) — Prime Minister Abe Shinzo’s Address at a Joint Meeting of the U.S. Congress Revived the Initiative in International Public Relations),” Web Magazine WEDGE Infinity (Mothly WEDGE), 20 May 2015. (Courtesy of WEDGE, Inc.) [June 2015]
Note: Original (Japanese) is available on the following site. http://wedge.ismedia.jp/articles/-/4973